Andrew Miller (Prime Series)

Andrew Miller has been a bullpen legend in The Show for years, and his Prime Series card continues that tradition. He's not a velocity monster, but his funky left-handed delivery and sweeping slider make him lethal in MLB 25 Stubs high-leverage situations.

His slider is his signature weapon, nasty against both righties and lefties, and now, unlike some past versions, he also has a circle change for added variety. This 96-rated card can be picked up for roughly 30,000 stubs, making him one of the best bullpen investments you can make if you have some MLB 25 Stubs saved up. Miller thrives late in games when every pitch matters.

Clayton Kershaw (Milestone Series)

To celebrate Clayton Kershaw reaching 3,000 career strikeouts, MLB The Show 25 released a Milestone Series card that quickly became a fan favorite. Kershaw's pitch mix is balanced and deadly: a fastball with sneaky life, a sharp slider, a slow 12–6 curveball, a circle change, and a sinker to jam hitters.

His delivery is notoriously hard to pick up, giving him an extra edge. While his card is obtainable for free through the Players Program, it does require a grind, but the reward is a top-tier starter who can anchor your rotation deep into the game's life cycle. For players looking to avoid spending MLB The Show 25 Stubs, Kershaw's grindable nature makes him an outstanding target.

Adrian Morejon (Spotlight Series)

Another high-impact lefty, Adrian Morejon's 96-rated Spotlight card is proof that you don't always need a 99 to dominate. His outlier sinker has sharp bite and sets up beautifully off his cutter, slider, and fastball. When used properly, Morejon can induce weak contact and rack up strikeouts against even the toughest opponents.

While he's not as widely used as Clemens or Kershaw, those who've faced him know how effective he can be, especially in bullpen situations where his mix of cheap MLB The Show 25 Stubs velocity and movement shines.